What are the pros and cons of voting to ban tourist rentals in my community?
Communities across Spain are holding EGMs to decide whether or not to continue allowing tourist rentals in their buildings, resorts and urbanisations, which has left many people wondering: “What way should I vote?”
Skip ahead to:
It’s worth noting that this does not affect those properties which already have a valid tourist licence, unless ownership is being transferred to a new person when the property is sold, in which case they would have to apply for a brand-new licence.
Tourist rental apartments are big business in Spain, acting as a source of income for many people, and despite the new legislation they are on the rise.
A recent study showed that two out of every three municipalities in Spain have tourist flats registered there, and in 64 towns in the country this property type accounts for more than 10% of all homes.
The government’s stated aim with their new legislation is to address the growing housing crisis by limiting property speculation and helping more people, especially young people and families, gain access to affordable permanent homes.
By enabling communities to control the number of holiday lets, the authorities hope to reduce the pressure on local housing markets, particularly in tourist-heavy areas.
However, the law has sparked mixed reactions, particularly in coastal areas such as
Murcia,
Alicante and many parts of Andalucía, where many owners are non-residents who rely on renting their homes to tourists for part of the year to help cover mortgage payments and maintenance costs.
While it is not obligatory for a community to now convene an Extraordinary General Meeting (EGM), many are choosing to do so in order to vote on the issue, and property owners are having to weigh up the arguments on both sides.
Why some owners are voting to ban tourist rentals
The issue is divisive, with people holding strong opinions on both sides, and there are good reasons both to support the ban or oppose it. Those in favour of limiting tourist rental apartments in Spain mainly focus on the conditions they live in on a day-to-day basis.
1. Improved quality of life for residents
One of the most frequently cited reasons for banning short-term holiday lets is the impact on the quality of life for full-time residents. Local communities often experience increased noise levels, late-night parties and loutish behaviour during peak tourist season, particularly when guests are not familiar with building rules or local customs. Limiting short-term stays could mean greater peace and quiet for residents and a return to more neighbourly living.
2. Less wear and tear on communal facilities
Another issue is the wear and tear on communal facilities. Frequent turnover of visitors can take its toll on lifts, swimming pools, gardens and shared spaces. Permanent residents argue that properties used as short-term rentals tend to generate more maintenance issues and that banning them will help preserve the overall condition of the development.
3. Greater security and control
Security is also a concern. A constant flow of strangers coming and going can make it harder to manage access to buildings or urbanisations, leading to worries about break-ins, theft and anti-social behaviour. By reducing the number of transient visitors, communities hope to improve safety and make it easier to hold people accountable for any damage or disturbance.
4. Stabilised property prices for locals
There is also a broader economic argument: reducing the number of tourist rentals may help stabilise or lower property prices and rental rates, making it easier for locals to stay in their towns or move out of the parental home. This is particularly relevant in cities and coastal areas where short-term letting has pushed up prices, forcing many people to look elsewhere for housing.
5. Strengthens the sense of community
Some also argue that limiting short-term lets will strengthen the social fabric of a community. In developments dominated by permanent residents, there tends to be a stronger sense of responsibility, cohesion and shared values, qualities which many say are being lost in tourist-heavy areas.
Why others are voting to allow them
On the other hand, many homeowners believe that banning tourist rentals could have unintended consequences, both for themselves and for the local economy.
1. Loss of rental income for owners
Many non-resident owners only visit their Spanish properties for a few weeks or months each year. For the rest of the time, they rent them out on a short-term basis to help cover their mortgage or justify the costs of maintaining a second home. If holiday letting is no longer an option, some say they may be forced to sell up, particularly if long-term rental is not financially viable or if they still want to enjoy some time in their property each year.
2. Impact on local businesses
Local businesses may also feel the pinch. In many tourist destinations, seasonal visitors bring vital income to bars, restaurants, shops and leisure services. Without the spending power of tourists, especially in the summer, businesses may struggle to stay afloat on the revenue generated by permanent residents alone.
3. Fewer incentives for second-home ownership and increased community fees
Some worry that fewer owners will be willing to invest in property in Spain if holiday lets are no longer permitted. This could lead to a decline in property values or result in urbanisations with a growing number of empty or underused homes. In turn, communities could see their community fees rise as fewer people contribute towards shared costs.
4. Grey market risk
There is also concern that banning short-term rentals may simply push some owners into the grey market, where they continue to rent without declaring the income or complying with local safety standards. This could create an uneven playing field and make enforcement more difficult for local authorities.
5. Unfair to part-time residents
Finally, many part-time residents feel it is unfair to restrict how they use their own property. If they maintain their homes well and follow the rules, they argue they should have the freedom to let them out legally and transparently when they are not using them.
What happens next?
Each comunidad de propietarios will eventually make its own decision on the issue, and a simple majority vote at an EGM could be enough to ban new tourist licences within a community. This happens at building level, instead of as a resort-wide rule.
Some blocks may choose to restrict short-term lets entirely, while others may allow them under certain conditions, such as limiting the number of properties that can be used for tourism, requiring minimum stays or charging additional community fees from those who wish to rent out their homes short-term.
As the law comes into effect, it is likely to reshape Spain’s property and tourism landscape, particularly in popular coastal areas. For owners, it is important to understand the implications of both sides before casting a vote as the decision could have long-term consequences for personal finances, property values and the local community.
Images: Archive/INE
article_detail
|
Address
Office 1: Monteclaro 1, 30389 La Manga Club / Office 2: Calle Delta del Danubio, 30385 Los Belones
Tel: 0034 868 707 917
Mobile: 0034 689 017 754
Loading
Heniam & Associates for Conveyancing, paperwork, legal advice and immigration throughout the Region of Murcia
Catering for the needs of expats living all over Spain, and particularly in the Costa Cálida and the Costa Blanca, Heniam & Associates offer a wide range of services including conveyancing, legal and administrative advice.
At the same time, their team of dedicated professionals appreciate the need to assist you in an easy and reliable manner, allowing you as much time as possible to enjoy your freedom, relax and make the most out of life in Spain. Without sacrificing efficiency, they offer personalised services to each and every client, listening to their needs in order to provide exactly the right service and desired outcome.
In the all-important field of Legal and Administrative Services, Heniam & Associates provide help in a wide range of matters including (but not limited to):
- Conveyancing
- Legal and professional communication assistance
- NIE and TIE Applications
- Commercial and company set-up and licensing
- Spanish health and administrative services
- Support and assistance with regulatory bodies
- Professional will writing services and advice on intestate inheritance laws (both in the UK and in Spain)
- Contract drafting (for businesses and individuals)
- Dispute resolution
- Digital signatures and certificates
Whether taking advantage of our conveyancing services or any other legal matter Heniam & Associates’ business partner HeniamLegal will represent you in the best possible way, excelling especially in their conveyancing service.
When buying a property in a foreign country it can be challenging to understand all of the
steps that have to be taken. Heniam knows that buying a home can be stressful and
they want to ensure that you have the resources that you need to make sure that the
transaction is as smooth as possible so that you can start to enjoy your new home without worrying about the details and any purchase pitfalls.
HeniamLegal will be on hand to assist you with every part of the process. They have
dedicated professionals on hand to assist you every step of the way ensuring that all
of the relevant checks and investigations are carried out and, of course, negotiating on your behalf and protecting your interests. You will always have the support you need with HeniamLegal and Heniam & Associates.
In addition, translation services are provided either for written documents or for occasions such as visits to the doctor or to administrative offices, and assistance is provided in finding the best deal on foreign currency transfers.
They have two offices in the Region of Murcia, one on La Manga Club and one in Los Belones:
Heniam & Associates La Manga Club
Monteclaro, 1
30389
La Manga Club
Murcia
Appointment only — contact to book a slot now
Heniam & Associates Los Belones
Calle Delta del Danubio, 3
30385
Los Belones
Murcia
Opening Times
- Monday to Friday: 9.30am - 2pm
Afternoon appointments available on request
To find out how Heniam & Associates can help you by taking the strain out of life in Spain, contact them for further information!
